Battery Replacement in the area around Fleming Island, FL averages $152.00, with prices ranging from $74.99 to $465.89 based on 15 verified prices from 15 nearby shops.
Showing nearby shops within 25 mi of Fleming Island · September 2026
Battery Replacement prices in Fleming Island, FL range from $74.99 to $465.89 at local auto repair shops, based on verified pricing data gathered from 15 shops across the area. Your car battery (typically 12V lead-acid) powers the starter motor to crank the engine and supplies electrical power to lights, ignition, and accessories. Prices for this service in Fleming Island vary by vehicle make and model, the grade of parts and fluids used, and whether you book with an independent shop, a franchise chain, or a dealership. Independent and chain repair shops in Fleming Island typically charge 20 to 40 percent less than dealerships for this service; dealerships may justify the premium for warranty-covered work or brand-specific diagnostics. All prices listed on this page were verified directly from shop websites or user-submitted receipts, and each carries a Last Verified date. For details on how PriceMyFix verifies prices, visit pricemyfix.com/about/methodology.
| Shop | Type | Price | Details | Verified | Distance | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jiffy Lube1585 Island Lane | Franchise | $74.99CouponBelow avg | Last verified 72 days agoby PriceMyFix | 0.4 mi | View Shop | |
| Jiffy Lube1548 Park Avenue | Franchise | $74.99CouponBelow avg | Last verified 58 days agoby PriceMyFix | 5.0 mi | View Shop | |
| Hanania Automotive Group7200 Blanding Boulevard | Dealership | $179.95Above avg | Includes battery and labor. | Last verified 126 days agoby PriceMyFix | 8.2 mi | View Shop |
| G&H Tires And Service10221 Beach Boulevard | Independent | $159.99 | Last verified 126 days agoby PriceMyFix | 16.5 mi | View Shop | |
| Quick Lane525 Outlet Mall Boulevard | Independent | $179.99CouponAbove avg | Includes 24-month free replacement warranty. | Verified 3 days agoby PriceMyFix | 21.7 mi | View Shop |
| Jiffy Lube13560 Atlantic Boulevard | Franchise | $74.99CouponBelow avg | Last verified 58 days agoby PriceMyFix | 22.2 mi | View Shop | |
| RPM Automotive304 3rd Street North | Independent | $179.99Above avg | Verified 14 days agoby PriceMyFix | 23.5 mi | View Shop | |
| Jiffy Lube1067 Atlantic Boulevard | Franchise | $74.99CouponBelow avg | Last verified 60 days agoby PriceMyFix | 23.9 mi | View Shop | |
| Jax Cruisers - Mobile Mechanic317 2nd Street | Independent | $179.99Above avg | Last verified 126 days agoby PriceMyFix | 24.8 mi | View Shop | |
| O'Reilly Auto Parts463346 Florida 200 | Independent | $109.99CouponBelow avg | Last verified 126 days agoby PriceMyFix | 37.5 mi | View Shop | |
| Amelia Repair LLC2112 Egret Lane | Independent | $129.99- $199.99Below avg | Last verified 126 days agoby PriceMyFix | 41.1 mi | View Shop | |
| Parks Ford of Gainesville3333 North Main Street | Dealership | $100.00CouponBelow avg | Verified 2 weeks agoby PriceMyFix | 46.1 mi | View Shop | |
| Gainesville Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram3000 North Main Street | Dealership | $465.89Above avg | Verified 2 weeks agoby PriceMyFix | 46.2 mi | View Shop | |
| City Auto Repair4488 Northwest 6th Street | Independent | $129.99CouponBelow avg | Most vehicles. | Verified 2 weeks agoby PriceMyFix | 46.3 mi | View Shop |
| Jenkins Kia of Gainesville2810 North Main Street | Dealership | $165.95 | Starting At | Verified 3 weeks agoby PriceMyFix | 46.4 mi | View Shop |
The average battery replacement in Fleming Island, FL costs $152.11 across 15 shops. The cheapest verified price is $74.99 at Jiffy Lube. Dealerships average $227.95 — 83% more than independents and chains in this area.
Trucks and SUVs with higher oil capacity may cost more. Check individual shop listings for vehicle-specific pricing.
Your car battery (typically 12V lead-acid) powers the starter motor to crank the engine and supplies electrical power to lights, ignition, and accessories. Modern vehicles also use the battery to stabilize the electrical system during transient loads from the alternator. Battery capacity is rated in Cold Cranking Amps (CCA) and reserve capacity (RC). Over time, internal lead plates shed material and electrolyte evaporates, reducing capacity. A battery that checks 'ok' on a simple voltage test can still fail a load test — the difference between 'charged battery' and 'healthy battery'.
Replace when: (1) the engine cranks slowly, especially in the morning, (2) you've had two or more jump-starts in a month, (3) your battery is 4+ years old in the Sun Belt or 5+ years nationally and shows any performance symptoms, (4) a load test (available free at AutoZone, O'Reilly, Advance Auto) shows the battery fails to hold voltage under simulated load, (5) the dashboard battery warning light illuminates — though that's usually the charging system, not the battery itself.
A dying battery is a reliability risk, not a safety risk in the mechanical sense. The danger is being stranded — a battery that barely cranks in your driveway may not crank at all after sitting in a hot parking lot for 8 hours. Being stranded in extreme heat (a common Sun Belt scenario) can be a serious health risk, especially for the elderly or those without roadside assistance. In modern vehicles, battery voltage also affects adaptive cruise control, lane keep assist, and ABS calibration thresholds — a degraded battery can cause intermittent fault codes in these systems.
Battery replacement has several price traps: (1) 'core charge' — most batteries carry a $10–$22 surcharge if you don't return the old battery; confirm this is included in the quoted price, (2) group size verification — using the wrong battery group size can cause fitment issues or electrical problems; confirm the shop is installing your vehicle's correct group size, not 'close enough,' (3) warranty period — batteries carry 1–3 year free replacement + prorated coverage; get the exact warranty terms in writing because many shops' 'lifetime warranty' is heavily prorated after year 1, (4) European vehicle owners: BMW, Mercedes, Audi, Volvo, and others require a 'battery registration' scan after replacement; without it, the BMS may not properly charge the new battery.
All prices verified from public sources and user submissions. Learn about our verification methodology.
